9 Heirloom Pumpkin Varieties We Love for Fall

heirloom pumpkin varieties

If you’re anything like me, the second pumpkins hit your market stalls, you start stocking up. You might even venture once or twice to the pumpkin patch before the season is through. But before you pick up yet another round orange specimen, consider all the fantastic heirloom pumpkin varieties out there. Here are just a few of ours to get you started.

1. Chioggia Sea Pumpkin

chioggia sea squash

Chioggia sea squash image via Shutterstock

This is definitely one of the most unique pumpkins you’ll see on this list. It’s native of Chioggia — yes, like Chioggia beets — in Italy. While the skin is anywhere from green to blue, the flesh is a deep yellow and nearly orange color and has a great sweetness when ripe. It’s the perfect pumpkin to use in pumpkin pie recipes, although if you have the space to roast it whole, it also makes for an impressive presentation vessel for your favorite pumpkin soup or for the more traditional pumpkin gnocchi.

2. Red Warty Thing Pumpkin

warty pumpkin

Image: VasekaPhotography

The Red Warty Thing definitely has a descriptive moniker! This pumpkin might look like an ornamental gourd, but don’t be fooled. When they are grown to a reasonable size, they actually share the shape of a more traditional pie pumpkin, and underneath their warty skin lies fine-grained flesh that doesn’t have the stringiness of some other pumpkin varieties. For this reason, it’s great roasted.

3. Jarrahdale Pumpkin

Jarrahdale pumpkin image via Shutterstock

This squash might seem rare to you, but in Australia and New Zealand it looks fairly familiar. The seed cavity is fairly small, so you get lots of flesh, and despite the grey skin, the interior is a nice, bright orange and the flesh is fruity and very aromatic. This one works very well in desserts.

4. Cotton Candy Pumpkin

cotton candy pumpkin

White pumpkin image via Shutterstock

The cotton candy pumpkin might seem like it would be cloyingly sweet, given its name, but this white-skinned pumpkin actually tastes fairly similar to a traditional pie pumpkin, even milder. The main difference is the color of the flesh, which is white. This variety is great for using in soups when combining with other fall vegetables like parsnip and sweet potato.

5. Iran Pumpkin

Green pumpkin image via Shutterstock

The Iran pumpkin is an interesting one for growers, as you’ll get to take full advantage of its bright colors as soon as it’s picked. The longer it matures, the more muted the greens and reds of the skin become. The flesh is a bit wetter and stringier than some, but it is sweet and flavorful, making it great for puréed dishes.

6. Long Island Cheese Pumpkin

long island cheese pumpkin

Long Island Cheese pumpkin image via Shutterstock

This pumpkin doesn’t get its name from its flavor but from its shape, which looks like a giant cheese wheel. The pumpkin itself has sweet flesh that’s very popular for making pumpkin pies due to its denseness and richness of flavor. These pumpkins keep for quite a while, so you can feel free to use them to decorate your front stoop for a few weeks before digging in.

7. Queensland Blue Pumpkin

Queensland blue pumpkin image via Shutterstock

Queensland blue pumpkins bear some resemblance to Jarrahdale pumpkins, though they tend to be a bit more blue than grey. The flesh of these pumpkins is quite dry and aromatic, making it perfect for frying in tempura batter.

8. One-too-Many Pumpkin

one-too-many pumpkin

One too many pumpkin image via Shutterstock

This pumpkin tends to have red, yellow, white and orange veins all around the outside of it, making it a very pretty one for decorating in the fall. Depending on the pumpkin, it might be round or oblong and have brighter or more muted colors. The skin is quite tough, but the flesh inside is tender, dense and sweet. Its name is surprising — you might never have too many of these. In fact, the name comes from the pumpkin’s resemblance to a bloodshot eye.

9. Rouge Vif d’Etampes

rouge vif d'étampes

Image: Hans

The Vif d’Etampes is also occasionally known as a Cinderella pumpkin due to its shape and size. It is particularly popular in France, where it gained renown as being a great pumpkin for French pumpkin soup. This is partly due to its rather mild flavor, which does not overpower other ingredients, and partly due to its color, more yellow than orange, which is more appreciated in many traditional French recipes.

How about you? What are your favorite kinds of heirloom pumpkins?

Related on Organic Authority

The Benefits of Pumpkin Seeds for Health and Beauty

Meatless Monday Roundup: 4 Pumpkin Recipes

17 Pumpkin Recipes You Shouldn’t Live Without

Pumpkin varieties image via Shutterstock

Emily Monaco is a food and culture writer based in Paris. Her work has been featured in the Wall... More about Emily Monaco