Best Baking Gifts for Sourdough, Sweets, & More: 17 Kitchen Favorites
Whether you’re making a sourdough loaf or a delicious homemade pie, these tried-and-true favorites are the best baking gifts and tools you can count on.
You know that friend. They consistently bring the most delicious dessert to the party, they perfected their sourdough starter well before lockdown, and their house always smells suspiciously like a French bakery. Yeah, that baker in your life deserves something special for the holidays.
Here at Organic Authority, we care about what we bake and what we bake it in. Because honestly, what’s the point of making wholesome food if sketchy chemicals are crashing the party via your bakeware? That’s why this guide focuses on clean, sustainable product picks that won’t add any unwanted ingredients to your delicious creations.
We’ve rounded up 17 baking gifts that we’ve actually tried and tested — not just admired from afar. These are the tools behind every crusty loaf, ooey gooey pie, and sheet pan dinner that doesn’t stick (we’re side-eyeing you, cheap bakeware).
Ready to find something your favorite baker will actually use? Scroll through and don’t be shy — most brands have their biggest sales this time of year, so if you like something it’s worth clicking to see what kind of discount you can get.
Table of Contents
- 1. Staub Cast Iron 4-Qt Dutch Oven
- 2. Baking Slab by Made In
- 3. Our Place Essential Griddle Pan Set (4-Piece)
- 4. ZWILLING Digital Kitchen Scale
- 5. Misen Stainless Steel Bench Scraper
- 6. GreenPan Reserve Bakeware (2-Piece Sheet Pan Set)
- 7. Xtrema 2-Qt Ceramic Loaf Pan
- 8. ZWILLING Pro 9’’ Bread Knife Z15 Serration
- 9. Caraway Glass Airtight Container Set
- 10. Our Place Hot Mitts (Set of 2)
- 11. Silicone Bread Sling
- 12. Misen Whisk
- 13. Made In Pie Serving Set
- 14. Stir Crazy Ceramic Mixing Bowls
- 15. KitchenAid 5.5-Qt Bowl-Lift Stand Mixer
- 16. Staub Stoneware Round Covered Brie Baker
- 17. Williams Sonoma S’mores Maker
- Final Thoughts
1. Staub Cast Iron 4-Qt Dutch Oven
This Staub Dutch oven is a workhorse and an heirloom piece. It’s perfect for baking sourdough, braising meats, making stews, or basically anything that needs even heat and moisture retention. The enameled cast iron holds heat beautifully, and the tight-fitting lid features unique self-basting spikes on the interior that circulate moisture back onto your food.
The textured black matte enamel interior never needs seasoning and ensures exceptional browning. It works on all stovetops (including induction) and is oven-safe to 500°F. You can go seamlessly from stovetop to oven to table — it’s truly gorgeous for serving. Made in France with exceptional craftsmanship, this is built to last generations.
Specs:
- 4-quart capacity (ideal for 2-4 people)
- Available in 17 colors
Price: $369.99 at time of publish
2. Baking Slab by Made In
This baking slab is my go-to for eye-popping, mouth-watering, oversized slab pies at holiday gatherings and summer cookouts. It’s the kind of dish that makes people stop and ask, “Wait, what is this? I have to try this.”
Designed with legendary Chef Nancy Silverton using a 202-year-old French porcelain recipe, this is the first baking slab of its kind. It delivers crisp corners and perfectly gooey middles every time, and it’s made in France without PFAS, PFOA, PTFE, lead, cadmium, aluminum, or BPA.
The real genius? It’s thermal-shock resistant, so you can go straight from the freezer to a hot oven without any drama. No pre-warming, no cracks. Try it for your next homemade focaccia bread, tarts, lemon bars, fudgy brownies, or really any baked good that benefits from even heat (so pretty much all of them). The naturally nonstick surface means easy cleanup, and it’s beautiful enough to serve from. Plus, a lifetime warranty makes this beauty a real winner.
Specs:
- Oven-safe to 650°F
- Dimensions: 15 ⅜”L x 9 ⅞”W x 1 ⅜”H
Price: $119 at time of publish
3. Our Place Essential Griddle Pan Set (4-Piece)
This set from Our Place is genuinely clever. It comes with two reusable silicone mats that fit perfectly into the large and mini griddle sizes, meaning you can finally ditch parchment paper. The large pan fits over two burners, and both griddles move seamlessly from stovetop to oven.
They’re equally perfect for Sunday brunch — fluffy pancakes, eggs, hashbrowns — as they are for cozy baking projects like lasagnas and holiday bars. The non-toxic Thermakind® ceramic nonstick is PFAS-free and genuinely effective, so you won’t find any stuck-on pancakes or burnt-on banana bread here.
Specs:
- Set of 4 pieces (Large Griddle, Mini Griddle, 2 Silicone Mats)
- Stovetop to oven-safe up to 450°F
- Available in 4 colors
Price: $159 at time of publish
4. ZWILLING Digital Kitchen Scale
If you love to bake, you need a kitchen scale. Baking is a science, and these measurements matter more than you think. You’ll be surprised at how many uses you’ll find for it, from weighing your flour for a perfect loaf to making sure you’ve got the right amount of ingredients for any dish.
This sleek ZWILLING scale will quickly become your most-used kitchen tool. It’s accurate to 0.1 oz/1g, weighs ingredients up to 22 lbs, and has a handy tare function for zeroing out container weight. Developed in Germany and designed in Milan, it’s minimalist, functional, and actually looks good on your counter. Plus, it’s cordless with a rechargeable battery, so no annoying cord or constant battery replacements.
Specs:
- Dimensions: 9.6″L x 7.4″W x 0.8″H
- Rechargeable battery with micro USB cord
Price: $49.99 at time of publish
5. Misen Stainless Steel Bench Scraper
Every baker needs a good bench scraper — it’s the secret weapon that sous chefs and line cooks have known about forever. Use it to lift, turn, and section dough, or scrape up flour and crumbs while you work. It’s as much a cleanup tool as it is a dough-cutter (and it’s great for cooking, too).
This Misen scraper has a comfortable silicone handle and can get tossed right in the dishwasher when you’re done. It’s one of those simple tools that completely changes how you work. Whether you’re making pizza dough or tackling homemade bagels, this scraper makes everything easier — and keeps your workspace cleaner in the process.
Specs:
- Stainless steel surface with silicone handle
- Dishwasher-safe
- Dimensions: 6.5″L x 4.5″H
- Lifetime warranty
Price: $24 at time of publish
6. GreenPan Reserve Bakeware (2-Piece Sheet Pan Set)
The GreenPan Reserve Bakeware features durable aluminized steel bodies with a ceramic nonstick coating that outperforms traditional luxury brands. These PFAS-free nonstick sheet pans are ideal for holiday cookie making, weeknight sheet pan dinners, roasted veggies, and more.
The ultra-strong, robust design delivers quick and even heating, resists warping and rusting, and offers lasting performance. The striking gold-tone handles aren’t just beautiful — they’re crafted with a premium PVD finish that’s wear- and corrosion-resistant. From crispy sheet-pan dinners to chewy cookies and gooey brownies, these pans handle it all.
Specs:
- Oven-safe up to 550°F
- Set includes: Quarter Sheet Pan (13″L x 9″W x 1″H) and Half Sheet Pan (18″L x 13″W x 1″H)
Price: $99.99 at time of publish
7. Xtrema 2-Qt Ceramic Loaf Pan
People are making the switch to Xtrema ceramic cookware for all the right reasons, and this loaf pan is a perfect example of why. It’s 100% pure ceramic cookware made without metals, so you never have to worry about unwanted chemicals leaching into your food.
Each piece is handcrafted by specialty Chinese ceramic artists — a culture that has produced ceramics for millennia. It’s triple-fired and ultra-purified at 2,500°F, making it incredibly durable, chip-resistant, and scratch-proof. This is an heirloom piece you won’t ever need to replace. It’s perfect for your next banana bread recipe, meatloaf, or any recipe that calls for a reliable loaf pan.
Specs:
- Microwave, oven, BBQ, freezer, and dishwasher-safe
- Dimensions: 11.5″L x 6.8″W x 3″H
Price: $75 $56 at time of publish
8. ZWILLING Pro 9’’ Bread Knife Z15 Serration
Every bread baker needs a great bread knife that doesn’t squish and tear lovingly made loaves. This ZWILLING Pro Bread Knife is specifically designed for slicing through beautiful artisan, rustic, and country-style breads with thick, crispy crusts.
The long, curved blade with unique Z-15.1 serration is German-made and built to deliver a clean slice. Forged from a single piece of special formula high-carbon stainless steel and ice-hardened with ZWILLING’s FRIODUR process, this knife stays sharper longer and won’t stain or chip. The curved bolster acts as an extension of the hand for a professional pinch grip, and it’s built to last a lifetime.
Specs:
- 9-inch blade with unique Z-15.1 serration
Price: $144.99 $115.99 at time of publish
9. Caraway Glass Airtight Container Set
I already love and trust Caraway for food storage, and now they’ve done it again with these gorgeous glass containers. They’re perfect for organizing your baking staples — flour, sugar, oats, whatever you’re storing. Made from high-resistance borosilicate glass, they’re non-toxic and won’t absorb odors or stains like plastic containers do.
The True Airtight Seal is the real standout here: just snap the button on each lid to lock in freshness and keep out air, moisture, and pests. The modular, stackable design maximizes space and will have your pantry looking gorgeous in no time.
Specs:
- 13-piece set includes:
- Small Glass Airtight Container With Lid (x2), 6” L x 6” W x 3” H / 1 qt / 1 L
- Medium Glass Airtight Container With Lid (x2), 6” L x 6” W x 6” H / 2.5 qt / 2.4 L
- Large Glass Airtight Container With Lid, 6” L x 6” W x 9” H / 4 qt / 3.8 L
- Stainless Steel Scoop
- Stainless Steel ¼ Measuring Cup
- Storage Organizer
- Dishwasher-safe
- Available in 6 colors
Price: $375 $265.50 at time of publish
10. Our Place Hot Mitts (Set of 2)
Ever found yourself still feeling the heat from your baking pan through your traditional fabric oven mitts? These Hot Mitts from Our Place are the answer. They’re made with heavy-duty silicone that can handle heat up to 550°F — way more protective than fabric — and the textured silicone grips help you handle hot pots and pans. My favorite feature is the extended forearm cuff that’s included for extra protection when reaching into hot ovens.
They’re also machine washable, so no more gross, stained mitts lurking in your drawer. Plus, they have a built-in magnet so you can stick them on your fridge, dishwasher, or microwave for easy storage. If you don’t have a magnetic surface, there’s also a loop for hanging. Simple and functional so you can focus on your baked goods.
Specs:
- Heavy-duty silicone, heat-resistant up to 550°F
- Extended forearm cuff for extra protection
- Built-in magnet for convenient storage
- Hanging loop included
- Available in three colors
Price: $45 $38 at time of publish
11. Silicone Bread Sling
If you bake sourdough in a Dutch oven, this silicone bread sling is essential. It lets you safely lower your dough into a hot Dutch oven without burning yourself or deflating the loaf. No more awkward parchment paper gymnastics.
The sling is made from food-grade silicone that’s heat-resistant up to 450-500°F, with long handles for a secure grip. After baking, use it to lift the bread out without any drama. It’s reusable, nonstick, and dishwasher-safe — and it’s also better for the environment than going through rolls of parchment paper. If you’re serious about bread baking, this simple tool makes a tricky step so much easier.
Specs:
- Includes two pieces
- Available in four colors and two shapes
- Fits most Dutch ovens
Price: $8.99-11.99 at time of publish (depending on shape and color)
12. Misen Whisk
A good whisk is essential for baking. It doesn’t need to be complicated, but it should be balanced, comfortable, and durable — and this one from Misen is all three (plus a lifetime warranty). The hybrid design combines a narrow whisk with a balloon whisk, featuring 20 stable stainless steel wires that tackle everything from scrambled eggs to meringues.
The platinum-cured silicone handle is heat-safe up to 450°F and comfortable enough for long whisking sessions without hand cramping. The stainless steel wires won’t rust or corrode, and the whole thing is dishwasher-safe. This is one of those basic tools you’ll use constantly — think batters, vinaigrettes, whipped cream, and everything in between.
Specs:
- 20 stainless steel wires
- Platinum-cured silicone handle
- 12″ length
Price: $19 at time of publish
13. Made In Pie Serving Set
This set includes Made In’s 1.5-Qt Pie Dish and matching Pie Server — which is all you really need to bake and serve perfect pies. The dish is made from that same 202-year-old French porcelain recipe from the baking slab I love, which gives you crisp crusts and even heating. The flat rim at a slight angle works beautifully with crimped, braided, or lattice crusts.
The 18/10 stainless steel pie server is designed to match the slope of the pie dish, so you can lift those delicate first slices without breaking the crust. The dish is thermal-shock resistant (freezer-to-oven safe) and naturally nonstick, plus the server won’t rust or stain. It’s the ideal set for pies, quiches, cheesecake, or chicken pot pie.
Specs:
- 1.5-qt pie dish
- 18/10 stainless steel pie server with pointed tip
- Lifetime warranty
Price: $94 $89 at time of publish (Save 5% by purchasing as a set)
14. Stir Crazy Ceramic Mixing Bowls
No kitchen is complete without mixing bowls, and this Stir Crazy set from Great Jones brings a playful, retro vibe to your counter. Made of durable ceramic stoneware, they’re a safe, non-toxic alternative to those old, stained plastic bowls that never quite get clean.
The set includes three stackable bowls in two joyful color options. They’re microwave, freezer, and dishwasher-safe, and strong enough to use with an electric handheld mixer. The high, fluted sides keep everything contained, and two spouts make pouring easy. Bonus: They’re cute enough to double as serving bowls.
Specs:
- Set of 3 stackable ceramic bowls (25 oz, 42 oz, 84 oz)
- Available in striped and classic color patterns
Price: $110 $75 at time of publish
15. KitchenAid 5.5-Qt Bowl-Lift Stand Mixer
This KitchenAid Stand Mixer is the ultimate baking investment. This 5.5-quart bowl-lift model has 11 speeds, including a delicate ½ speed designed for folding in light ingredients like blueberries or egg whites without deflating them. It can handle everything — kneading bread dough, whipping cream, mixing cookie dough, you name it.
The bowl-lift design provides a 3-point locking bowl for maximum stability when mixing heavy, dense ingredients, with 2x the power in the bowl compared to tilt-head models. You can easily mix 11 dozen cookies, knead over 7 lbs of bread, or mash 6 lbs of potatoes.
Specs:
- 5.5-quart stainless steel bowl
- Includes coated flat beater, dough hook, and 6-wire whip
- Compatible with 10+ attachments (sold separately)
Price: $499.95 at time of publish
16. Staub Stoneware Round Covered Brie Baker
This Staub Brie Baker is way more versatile than it looks. Yes, it’s specially designed for perfectly baked cheese, but it’s also great for small casseroles, heating dips, baked vegetables, or storing leftovers. The elegant French-made stoneware goes straight from oven to table, so you can serve beautifully without transferring.
Made from vitreous glass porcelain-enamel, it’s highly resistant to scratches, impact, and thermal shock. The stoneware retains heat exceptionally well and won’t absorb moisture, keeping your food at the perfect temperature. It’s microwave, freezer, broiler, and oven-safe up to 570°F. The tight-fitting lid retains moisture, and the large handles make maneuvering easy. Plus, who doesn’t want a brie baker in their kitchen arsenal?
Specs:
- Dimensions: 9.49″L x 7.99″W x 3.39″H
- Includes lid
Price: $49.99 at time of publish
17. Williams Sonoma S’mores Maker
Okay, so this S’mores Maker isn’t exactly bakeware, but what’s a baker without a delicious treat to reward themselves with? This charming set brings campfire vibes right into your kitchen so you can enjoy s’mores all year long — no logs required.
The set includes a roasting chimney with a stainless-steel fuel can, grill top, four roasting sticks with easy-grip, stay-cool handles, and a partitioned ceramic tray that keeps your graham crackers, chocolate, and marshmallows organized. It’s a fun, unique gift that celebrates the joy of sharing dessert and turns any night into a cozy occasion. Perfect for entertaining or family fun.
Specs:
- Set includes roasting chimney (with a stainless steel fuel can), grill top, 4 roasting sticks with stay-cool handles, and partitioned ceramic tray
- Dimensions: 12 ¼”L x 6″W x 12 ¼”H
Price: $49.95 at time of publish
Final Thoughts
Here’s the truth about baking: having the right tools makes all the difference. A flaky, golden pie crust versus a soggy bottom? That’s your baking dish doing its job — or not. Quality tools aren’t just nice to have; they directly affect how your finished dishes turn out.
When you invest in pieces like a thermal-shock resistant pie dish or a Dutch oven that doesn’t chip enamel into your food, you’re setting yourself up for success. These aren’t tools you’ll replace every few years — they’re built to last and get better with use. Whether you’re planning a gift for someone special or finally upgrading your own kitchen, choose tools that work as hard as you do. Your baked goods (and everyone who eats them) will see the difference.
