Caraway Food Storage Review: Is it Worth It? Chef Tested

After a year of testing the Caraway Food Storage Set, our resident chef and founder Laura Klein shares her review and experience. The good, the bad, and the beautiful – read her full review.

Image of Caraway Food Storage in cream, on a white marble countertop, prepped alongside a flat stovetop with amCaraway Home cookware Fry Pan and a covered saucepan to the rear. There's also a terracotta vase with fresh lilies, black marble salt and pepper shakers, and a veined marble backsplash.
Credit: Image courtesy of Caraway Home

Over the past year, I’ve put Caraway Food Storage to the test. This ain’t my first testing rodeo. As a trained chef, rabid home cook, and founder of Organic Authority, I’ve had the opportunity to test a lot of food storage containers, kitchen tools, cookware, appliances, and more. (Read some of our most-read guides on the best non-toxic bakewareour favorite clean cookware brands and our roundup of best ceramic cookware.) 

Some live up to the hype, and others fall flat. My job is to test the heck out of these items, then relay my experiences to help you make informed decisions on the best kitchenware to bring into your home (I love my job!). Here’s my Caraway Food Storage review.

Keep reading to uncover an exclusive offer for the Organic Authority community. 

Food Storage + The Food Waste Problem

Image of a food prep session displayed on a white marble kitchen island with wood cutting board. Caraway Home food storage containers (in white and blue) filled with fresh berries, cut melon, olives, and microgreens.
Image courtesy of Laura Klein + Organic Authority Studio

Food storage and food waste are two huge pain points for today’s households. Keep reading to discover the startling statistics.  

As an educated, conscious consumer you know you don’t want to store your food in plastic containers that quickly degrade, warp from the heat of the dishwasher, and may leach chemicals into your food if you pop them in the microwave for a quick reheat sesh. We’re looking at you, Tupperware (remember the famous brightly colored plastic containers?). 

Oh, and then there are the lids. The lids always get separated, no matter how hard you try to keep them organized. Hiding in some far-off drawer where you think you’ll find them but alas, you never do. Then you end up jerry-rigging some Frankenstein solution like using the wrong size lid, because that’s all you can find, and securing it with a rubber band because it doesn’t fit.  

And let’s not forget about the refrigerator. It ends up looking like a disorganized mess. And that mess is one of the biggest culprits of food waste because you can’t find anything — because it’s forgotten. 

Want more top picks? Sign up for the newsletter for more well-researched non-toxic living guidance + smart wellness advice.

Consider America’s Food Waste Statistics

Image of a huge amount of dirty apples decomposing in a landfill showcasing the problem that when do not store food in glass food storage containers properly, there is considerably more wasted food, which, when it decomposes, releases greenhouse gases.
Image sourced from Unsplash

Food waste. Globally, it’s a huge problem. In America, it’s heartbreaking, particularly as an advanced, developed nation. 

I’m the one whose refrigerator is full of tiny mason jars and containers that save the last few bites of food, hoping that someone in my family will eat it in the next few days. Like this easy roasted chicken and carrots sheet pan dinner. Does it always work? No. Many times I end up throwing it out or composting it, if it’s compostable. 

When I throw out food, here are just a few things that run through my mind:

  • How much money did I just waste?
  • How much of this is going to the landfill?
  • How much can I compost?
  • Who else could have been nourished by this food?
  • I’m so lucky to be living in a place where we have access to clean water and plenty of food to feed our family. 

The food waste statistics are shocking and it’s something that each and every one of us has control over and can help reduce. 

  • According to Earth.org, “In 2020, Americans threw away more food than the citizens of the UK, Germany, France, Italy and Sweden combined.” That’s shocking. As a developed nation we can do better and become part of the solution — which will take each and every one of us.
  • On a daily basis, every American throws out, on average, about one pound of food.1
  • US consumers waste about one-third of all purchased food or about $1500 in groceries per year for a household of four.2 That’s a lot of money that could go towards something else like college tuition or a mortgage.
  • Households account for the largest portion of US food waste. Perhaps that’s the good news. That means there is something that you and I can do about it.
  • Greenhouse gasses — according to the World Wildlife Federation, food waste that ends up in landfills in America is equivalent to the greenhouse emissions of 37 million cars.  

To compound it all, when we waste food, resources that go into it — the water, energy, land, labor, and even chemicals that go into producing it and polluting our earth, are wasted as well. 

Is Caraway Food Storage Worth it? 

image of caraway food storage in use on countertop in cream and navy blue containers with hand reaching for berries.
Caraway’s Food Storage Set can help you store everyday food items like fresh cut fruit, snacks, veg, dinner’s left overs and more.  Credit: Image via Laura Klein and Organic Authority Studio

Whether or not they’re worth it, depends on what’s important to you. Sure, they may be slightly pricier than some other glass storage containers out there. But they say you get what you pay for, and that’s the truth. 

If you value a bargain above these things, maybe Caraway isn’t for you. However, in my year plus of testing I’ve put these babies through a lot and the quality is apparent. So, in that way, these are for you even if you lean to the frugal side because you won’t be replacing these containers any time soon.

Next up, let’s consider single-use plastic bags. We’ve all struggled with completely eliminating those (including me). Sometimes you just need one, whether it’s to pack a lunch for your next hike or need something that takes up zero space on a trip. The Caraway Storage Container Set comes with small Dot & Dash inserts, which are just the thing for snacks for the trail. 

Let’s get into the nitty-gritty and find out exactly what this food storage set is made of, and is it really worth it?  

Exclusive! Save an extra 10% on Caraway Home Cookware Products when you shop our links. Discount applied at checkout. Shop now before the sale ends.

Grab a gift code with purchase March 11 – March 31.

  • Spend $95 get $25 gift code
  • Spend $195 get $50 gift code
  • Spend $395 get $100 gift code
  • Spend $795 get a $200 gift code

Gift code sent post-purchase.

What’s Caraway’s Food Storage Set Made Of?

Image of Caraway Food Storage Containers in navy and cream in Laura Klein's refrigerator, two shelves shown with fresh greens, carrots, peppers, honeydew and watermelon
Image by Laura Klein and Organic Authority Studio

The set is ceramic-coated (interior and exterior) borosilicate glass. It is non-toxic and free of PFOAs, PFAs, BPA, BPS, lead, cadmium, and toxic metals (you can email them for their test reports if you wish to see them). Their dedication to transparency is one of the things I love about Caraway.

Caraway’s Food Storage Set comes in similar colors as their classic cookware sets (see the rundown on our favorite Caraway sets, here), cream, sage, gray, navy, perracota, and a new color mist.

Exclusive! Save an extra 10% on Caraway Home Cookware Products when you shop our links. Discount applied at checkout. Shop now before the sale ends.

What Comes in a Food Storage Set?

Image of Caraway Food Storage Containers in Navy, a full set in their storage organizer on a white marble counter with white cabinetry above next to a bright window and small succulent.
Image courtesy of Laura Klein and Organic Authority Studios

When you purchase the whole food storage set, it comes with 14 pieces. You get five ceramic coated storage containers of different sizes with corresponding lids, one large container, two medium-sized containers, and two small containers. 

A complete set also comes with four Dot & Dash Inserts, that are surprisingly useful. Particularly if you’re a sauce or dip lover like I am, and or take your food on the go. To use, fill them with your favorite sauces or snack-y items, and put the Dot & Dash Inserts in the ceramic containers. And if you’re on the go, use the included container straps to ensure your lids stay closed. 

Image of Laura Klein, chef and editor-in-chief of Organic Authority, pictured in her own kitchen at her kitchen island with various food prep items stored in Caraway Home's food storage containers.
Image courtesy of Laura Klein + Organic Authority Studio

And then there are the three magnetic storage organizers to store everything — including the lids. You can either put the organizers on a countertop, if you have the space, or put it in a cupboard or drawer, depending on your space and design aesthetic. 

You can buy the whole set for $245, down from $305 (at the time of this writing, plus 10% exclusive discount) or you can buy the food storage and the Dot and Dash Containers individually anywhere from $22 up to $50 each. 

Exclusive! Save an extra 10% on Caraway Home Cookware Products when you shop our links. Discount applied at checkout. Shop now before the sale ends.

My Experience Testing the Caraway Storage System

Image of Caraway Food Storage Containers in navy on Laura Klein's counter in the storage organizer alongside a succulent plant and a glass bowl of oranges.
Image via Laura Klein and Organic Authority Studio

First, let’s talk presentation (aka the unboxing!). When I opened the box, I was greeted with a beautiful and thoughtfully packaged (there’s zero plastic in the shipping box) food storage set that I couldn’t wait to start using. 

The next thing I noticed were the air-tight seals. They work really well. So well, sometimes I have to use a butter knife to pop open the lid, which at times can be a bit annoying. But, I’d rather have a tight seal that keeps food fresh and weird smells in or out (onion, garlic, broccoli, or kale anyone?), and the confidence I can take food on the go when needed. 

Caraway’s Glass Food Storage Containers: Many Sizes, Many Uses

Image of Caraway Food Storage Containers in navy and cream in Laura Klein's refrigerator, two shelves shown with fresh greens, carrots, peppers, and purple cabbage.
Image by Laura Klein and Organic Authority Studio

Another check in the win category? Each size of container comes in a distinct shape, making them easy to identify in the fridge. So if you have staples that you batch cook on a weekly basis, the sizes help you spot those food items quickly, particularly if you put them in the same place in your refrigerator. 

For example, I batch cook food for my dog weekly (yep, I’m that dog mom!), and I store it in the large square container, and put it in the same place in my refrigerator. That way, I always know where it is, and it never gets lost, and nothing is wasted.  

Reheating food

Now let’s talk reheating food. I love to batch cook meals on the weekend and portion things out for the week. What’s great about these containers is you can reheat food in them in the oven! I don’t use a microwave (I don’t like the way it makes food taste), so having the ability to take something from the refrigerator and put it in the oven as is, is sooo useful. I don’t have to dirty another pan if I don’t want to. 

One important note about reheating food in the oven is that the lids are not oven-safe. So if you need to keep the food covered while you reheat it, you’ll need to use something like tin foil or place a small baking sheet over it for a waste-free option. 

image of sprouts, Tziki dip, Italian Olives, pita chips and fresh berries all stored in Caraway's food storage containers.
Image via Laura Klein and Organic Authority Studio.

Reducing plastic in the kitchen

Upon testing the Caraway Food Storage Set, I’m happy to report, it solved another Klein kitchen woe. One of my weaknesses is cheese, and I hate storing cheese in plastic. It drives me nuts that cheese is sold in plastic (it’s not good for the cheese either, which can result in flavor and texture defects). 

So when I buy cheese, once I get it home, I remove it from the plastic, wrap it in parchment paper, and store it in a container. And Caraway’s storage containers are kind of perfect for this with their air-tight seals. After a year of testing, I’ve yet to pull cheese out of one of these containers, and have it be dry (I still wrap it in parchment first).  

A pretty and organized refrigerator

In addition to their functionality, I have to admit that I love the aesthetics of the food storage containers. They inspire me to want to use them because they make a pretty and organized refrigerator. I can actually find things simply by identifying the shape or looking through the glass lid. This means I’m more likely to spot what I need (or need to use up!) and waste less food.

Exclusive! Save an extra 10% on Caraway Home Cookware Products when you shop our links. Discount applied at checkout. Shop now before the sale ends.

Good Things to Know About Caraway’s Food Storage Containers

Image of Caraway Food Storage set stored in organizer on a counter in navy, apart from one container which sits out filled with cut watermelon on its lid. Next to it on the white marble counter is a small wood cutting board with watermelon and a glass bowl of clementines to the back right.
Image courtesy of Laura Klein and Organic Authority Studios

Caraway’s food storage set is not leakproof and not a fit for liquids on the go (which a lot of food storage containers are not). This is where something like a mason jar is really handy for any liquids like soups to take with you or simply to store liquids in your refrigerator.

If you take food on the go, Caraway’s storage containers come with straps that help keep the lids close. However, I’ve found that the containers have such a tight seal, I don’t find they are really needed. But, if I were taking food with me, I would use them because it’s not fun to clean up spilled food.

Speaking of clean up, when it comes to washing they are super easy to clean. They have a ceramic coated nonstick surface so everything comes off pretty effortlessly. They are dishwasher safe so you can simply pop them in the dishwasher for an easy clean.

Image of Caraway Food Storage with organizers in a cabinet with the door open, sitting next to a cutting board and folded kitchen towels.
Image courtesy of Caraway Home

Like the cookware, you want to stay away from metal utensils as they could scratch the ceramic coating. Stick with soft cookware tools like wood or silicone (I hope you don’t have any plastic tools, as they will melt!).

If you reheat food in the oven or microwave, know you must use oven mitts. And you’ll also want to use a trivet when the container is hot to protect countertops. Treat them as you would a hot baking dish out of the oven.

Do not take a container from the freezer with frozen food and put it in the microwave or oven, this could cause your storage container to crack. Allow your frozen food to thaw before reheating it.

When filling your containers for use in the freezer, don’t overfill them. Leave some space to allow for food to expand.

Allow hot food to cool before you put it in your refrigerator.

Below is a handy checklist. 

Good to Know Checklist

  • Use the straps for when you take food on the go. 
  • The sets are not leakproof. Use mason jars for liquids.
  • Use oven mitts when removing reheated food in containers from the oven or microwave.
  • Stay away from metal utensils, use wood, silicone and the like.
  • Don’t overfill them, food does expand (I’ve tested this and it’s true!).  

Oven + Microwave Tips

  • If you’ve frozen food in the storage containers, allow the frozen food to thaw before reheating in the oven or microwave. 
  • Do not put your containers with food in an over hotter than 450 degrees Fahrenheit. 
  • Do not put an empty container in the oven or microwave.
  • Lids do not go in the oven or microwave.

Washing Tips:

  • You can put the containers and lids in the dishwasher. 
  • Caraway recommends that you remove the gasket around the lids for a thorough dry. I’ve never done that, and it seems like a time-consuming step. Perhaps I should do it.

Exclusive! Save an extra 10% on Caraway Home Cookware Products when you shop our links. Discount applied at checkout. Shop now before the sale ends.

Tips on how to reduce food waste at home:

  • Organize your refrigerator and put things at the front that need to be eaten right away. This way, you can see the food you need to eat within the next 24-48 hours, and you can prioritize your meals and snacks.
  • Freeze food that you won’t eat right away.
  • Know what is, and is not, compostable and keep food scraps out of landfills.
  • Take the time to plan, make grocery lists, and meal prep.
  • Consider having a “use it/eat it up” meal every week. Or as my mother used to say “must go” meal.

Exclusive! Save an extra 10% on Caraway Home Cookware Products when you shop our links. Discount applied at checkout. Shop now before the sale ends.

If you’ve tried Caraway’s food storage containers, please share your experiences with the community in the comments below.

Read More on Organic Authority

Image of cover image for video with text overlayed reading "Blender chocolate mousse with coconut cream, amaretto, and fresh berries" image shows two servings of the mousse with amaretto and fresh mint in the background.
Image courtesy of Organic Authority Studios

The Best Lion’s Mane Recipe: Pasta with Parm, Fresh Herbs, & Peas [Video]

How to Cook Delicious Oatmeal Every Time [Video]

Luscious & Easy Chocolate Mousse Made In the Blender [Video]

P.S. Did you know? Organic Authority has its own nutrition and wellness shop to meet your needs and help you take control of your health. Shop clean supplements for energy, sleep, inner beauty for skin support, protein, workouts, pantry items and more. Shop The Organic Authority Shop now. 

*Note! This article contains affiliate links that are independently sourced and vetted by our editorial team, which we may earn a commission on. This helps us reduce the number of ads we serve on Organic Authority and help deliver you a better user experience. We are here to help you navigate the overwhelming world of consumer products to source and uncover thoughtfully made, conscious clean products. Learn more

Sources:

1. https://earth.org/food-waste-in-america/
2. https://fortune.com/2022/12/12/how-much-food-do-americans-waste-every-year-one-third/

Laura is a trained chef with roots in the organic food movement and brings intelligence, intoxicating energy and girl-next-door... More about Laura Klein, Chef & Wellness Expert

Tags: